There was some sentimentality about how nice for retiring star pitcher CC Sabathia to hit another milestone, his 250th career win, against the team that helped him get his first. Sabathia’s MLB debut on April 8, 2001, was with the Indians (in this same stadium), but he threw a no-decision. His first win came 5 days later when the Indians played the Tigers in Detroit. Now, 248 wins later, that pesky #250 still lingers in potential.
Sabathia got the start in today’s game and got a bit roughed up by the Indians’ bats in this middle game of the weekend series. He threw just 69 pitches through 5 innings, gave up 7 hits, a walk, and 4 runs, and struck out 5 Cleveland batters.
In fact, he didn’t give up much until the 4th inning. A lead-off single moved to 3rd on a double and then scored on a sacrifice fly. A questionable double scored another run, and the umpire review confirmed it wasn’t quite a home run. A snazzy, highlight reel worthy double play ended the inning for Sabathia.
After a rough, but scoreless 5th, the Yankees closed out the game with relievers. First, Jonathan Holder found his own problems in the 6th. A lead-off single scored as part of a 1-out 2-run home run. Then a 2-out solo home run pushed the Indians further ahead.
Luis Cessa had a better turn with a clean 7th inning, but his 8th inning found the same stumbles. A lead-off walk moved to 3rd on a 1-out single and then scored on a sacrifice fly. The Indians’ bats just were working throughout the game.
But the Yankees’ had their moments. In the 1st, with 1 out, LeMahieu singled and then scored as part of Didi Gregorius’ big 2-out 2-run home run, Gregorius’ first home run of the season. But then, after the Yankees fell to the Indians’ lead, they struggled to find another opportunity.
In the 7th, with a new pitcher, Gregorius led-off with a single and ended up at 2nd on a throwing error. Gleyber Torres’ double scored Gregorius, and a ground out moved Torres to 3rd. After a pitching change and Frazier’s walk, Gio Urshela’s sacrifice fly scored Torres for just one more Yankee run today.
Final score: 8-4 Indians
CC K-Count: 3033
Again, this is quite the sentimental series for CC Sabathia and his family. This is where his career began, starting with being drafted by the Indians in 1998 (1st round, 20th overall pick), and debuting just 3 years later at the age of 20. It’s where he built his family, became a father, and found his favorite sub shop (which he visited before yesterday’s game).
But then he was traded to the Brewers in 2008 for their postseason run. Being a free agent in that off-season, the big 2007 Cy Young Award winner signed with the biggest team ever and helped take them to the World Series that year. And New York is where he’ll end his storied career. But it all started in Cleveland, not so much his “mistake on the lake”.